Date: Mon, 22 Dec 2014 19:25:32 -0600
From: Steven LaVigne <bullwaters@gmail.com>
Subject: Fucking Under the Mistletoe, Part 2

Nifty.org needs your support in order to continue to provide stories like
this one without charge.  Please donate whatever you can.

Fucking Under the Mistletoe, Part 2 by Bull Waters

I didn't feel like going out on this rather icy New Year's Eve.  Besides,
my friends had given me some hot new CDs and a couple of books I'd been
wanting to read, so, just like on Christmas Eve, when I'd had a great time
with Santa and his son, Nick, Junior. I put on my red jockstrap and
low-neck green tank top again.  The mistletoe was still hanging over my
bed, so I stacked the CDs, opened a book, and settled in for the night.

The book I'd selected was about gay sex.  Naturally, it made me horny. I
put it down and looked on the table, where the long, double-headed black
dildo that Nick had left for me was lying next to the bottle of lube I'd
gotten from Santa. I'd been using one end of the dildo all week long, so I
was clean inside. I lubed the dildo and slowly began to fuck myself, but I
made a New Year's wish that someone would share the dildo with me sometime.

My eyes were closed as I dreamily pushed the rubber flesh into my boyhole,
I felt a hand on top of mine. When I opened my eyes, I was looking into the
face of Nick, wearing nothing but a green jockstrap and a red tank top that
showed off the hair on his chest.  He gave me a deep kiss and before I knew
what was happening, we were sitting on the floor, cock to cock, our legs
around one another rocking back and forth with the other end of the dildo
inside Nick.

"Happy New Year, my love!" he said as he kissed me again.

"How?but?ah," I started to ask, but he was taking the tank off me and he
pecked at one nipple while pinching the other into hardness. I moaned as he
did this.  This elf knew how to trigger what turned me on, that's for sure!
Then he took both of our cocks in his hand and started jerking, and said,
"Mine is going to replace the dildo in your ass, and yours is going to
replace it in mine!  We'll both cum into the new year, together!"

With that, he started stroking us both, moving around so the dildo came
loose and fell out of my ass.  He raised my legs and started to rim my hot
ass. Of course it felt good, and has he worked his tongue inside me, I
whimpered. Nick knew he'd found my g-spot. I gazed into his eyes as he slid
his hard ten incher inside me. It felt so good and natural, I never wanted
him to remove it!

"Yeah, that's it, take this hard elfcock into that magnificent crevasse of
yours," Nick whispered seductively. "Oh baby, Santa's boy is going to fuck
you all night long! I never want to leave this place!  Oh, fuck!  He pumped
harder and squirted inside me. "Oh fuck, baby! Take my hot load of
elf-green sperm!"

Green sperm?  What the hell did he mean?  Then I looked into his eyes and
realized that Nick wouldn't lie about that!  He was, indeed, and elf, and
of course his sperm would be green. It made sense to me.

After Nick's cock softened, I moved down to his crotch and started to lick
the cum off him. It was definitely a light shade of green, but it tasted
delicious, almost like eggnog.

He moved into my arms and we made out.  His fingers tenderly worked over my
nipples, and before too long, he was teasing them again with his
mouth. Then he began kissing his way down my stomach and rubbed his nose in
my pubic hair, before his tongue began licking up to the uncut head of my
hardening member.  Holding it with one hand, Nick pulled out the dildo,
which was still stuck in his ass. Then he climbed onto my crotch and guided
my hardware into his software, moaning as more and more of me disappeared
inside. Meanwhile, I noticed that his nipples, hidden within a forest of
greenish black hair, were getting quite perky. I moved my hands to either
side his Nick's hips, but he took them and told me to pinch his nipples as
hard as I could. I did and he screamed, "Oh, fuck! That feels so good,
baby! Yes, yes, yes, pinch those babies hard! We're both gonna shoot at the
same time!"

And, with that, I spurted inside him as his cock spurted all over my chest
and stomach. Fuck, this elf sure knew how to turn me onto a sex machine!
Nick scraped his finger along my chest and, gathering up some of his warm
cum, fed it to me. Then, he used his hand and we both licked it up. He
leaned down and we started kissing deeply.

I'd never had sex to equal this before!  I thought I was falling in love
with this hot man, elf or not!  Nick could tell what I was thinking,
because he said, "I'm falling in love with you, too, but you know we can
only be fuck buddies because my life is with my dad up North." When I
started pouting he told me, next time I come, I'm going to bring my twin
brother, Seth. He likes it when he gets fucked by two hard cocks at the
same time. You should hear him scream when I fuck him and dad enters from
behind!"

I was about to ask him questions about his brother, but the next thing I
knew, Nick had disappeared almost in the same way he'd arrived.  I fell
asleep more than satisfied, and when I was in the shower the next morning,
I noticed traces of green mixed with the water as I rinsed off my chest and
stomach. Since this is a new year, I decided to write down what's happened
between Santa, Nick and me.  I thought about what the future may hold, too.

I wonder if anyone believes me.