Chapter 17 – One Last Surprise

Our lives – and loves – continued as they had been for the last two years. The
girls spent many nights in my bed, sometimes both girls and sometime just one.
Often it was just a 'cuddle and kiss' night, but there were frequent sessions
of lovemaking. On occasion there was a 'girls only' night and both girls
looked sated the next morning.

The two sets of 'grandparents' were kept abreast of things and continued to
support us. I had wondered if things would change after the 'revelation day'
as I called it and it did, but in a nice way. Now that things were out in the
open it seemed we had more get togethers with one or the other or both of the
couples. Sometimes it was just sit and chat, sometimes a meal and on a couple
of occasions a trip to Harry and Helen's lakeside cottage. The girls liked
that and spent much of the time in the water. I couldn't help notice the
attention that was paid to them by the boys in the cottage next door. The
girls teased the boys mercilessly flaunting their bodies, but also became good
friends with the boys.

One evening shortly after Tara's seventeenth birthday, as we were having a
night to ourselves, Tara surprised me with a request.

"Dad, just listen and don't interrupt, okay?" she asked. I looked at her with
a bit of surprise on my face. She continued, "I've been listening to a few
girls, not my friends but girls in my class, and they've been talking about
getting fucked..." she started to blush "...in the ass. Now don't say
anything, just listen. I've been thinking about this for a while and Grandma
Mabel and Grandma Helen and I have had several long discussions about this,
but I want to try it once." She stopped and looked straight into my eyes.
"Daddy, would you please fuck my ass."

I was quite surprised at this request and was about to say no when Tara
continued. "You always said that you'd do anything I asked as long as it
wouldn't hurt me. If Tamara and Audrey can take a cock in their ass, so can I.
I don't know if I'll like it unless I try. I promise if it starts to feel
really uncomfortable, I'll tell you and we can stop. I got a vibrator that's
bigger around that my usual one and I've been trying it and it doesn't feel
too bad." She stopped and looked at me.

"Well, I'm a bit uneasy with this but..." holding my finger up to stop her
interruption "I'll agree as long as you promise to stop me if things start to
hurt." She nodded 'yes'. I continued. "I don't know if Mabel told you this but
before we started making love, Mabel gave me two rules to obey. First, you had
to ask me to do something and second, I couldn't hurt you. I have always
obeyed those rules and I have no intention stopping now." Tara looked at me
and a tear came to her eye.

"Daddy, I know about those rules and rule two is the thing that I like most
about our lovemaking – no pain." She paused, "well, okay, maybe a teeny bit of
pain when you bite my nipples but that's a good pain." She smiled. "Thank you
for agreeing to do allow me to experience anal sex."

"Do you want to do it tonight?" I asked.

"No, I talked to Ashley and told her that if you agreed – and I was sure you
would – that I'd ask her to stay at one of the grandmas for a night. I'll let
you know when. If you see the tube of K-Y goop on your bed you'll know that
tonight is the night." and with that last statement she started to grin. We
spent the balance of the night as a 'kiss and cuddle' night.

Two days later when I got home and went into the bedroom to change my clothes
there prominently on my pillow was a tube of K-Y lube. 'So tonight it is' I
thought to myself. I was still a bit uneasy but I'd told Tara I's do it and I
would.

Ashley had come home and as I went into the kitchen to start supper, she came
in with her backpack. "I'm going to Grandma Helen's for supper and staying
overnight. I've got everything I need and I'll just go to school from there."
She ran over and gave me a kiss. "You and Tara have a good night and I'll see
you after school tomorrow." and with that she was out the door and gone.

A few minutes later, Tara came home. "Hi Daddy, did you see my signal?" she
asked with a smile. "Oh yes, I saw it." I paused for a moment then continued.
"Tara, I definitely will honour my promise, but I'm still a bit uneasy. Are
you absolutely sure you want to do this?" Tara got a stern look on her face.
"Dad! How many times do I have to tell you? Yes, I want you to fuck me in the
ASS!"

The last statement shook me up a bit, but it was now crystal clear what Tara
wanted – and I would do what she asked. We had a leisurely supper and watched
a bit of TV. About 8:30 I suggested we retire to my bedroom. "I think we need
to take a shower tonight before we go to bed. Coming with me?" I asked. Tara
smiled. "Isn't that cumming _in_ me?" I laughed and jokingly scolded her for
her comment. "I'll cum in you later – in your ass." and with that I took her
hand and pulled her into the shower. We washed each other in our usual
fashion, but both of us was careful not to make the other cum. Finally we
returned to the bed. I took Tara in my arms and hugged and gave her open-mouth
kisses. All the while I was playing with her boobs and pussy. It was evident
by how wet she was that now was the time.

"Tara, I want you to get up on your knees but fold your arms so that your
shoulders are lower than your ass... good, now spread your legs apart... yep,
now arch you back down so that your ass is pushed out... yes, just like that."
I grabbed the K-Y and put a gob on my fingers and lubed my cock. I put some
more lube on my fingers and put them on Tara's anal ring. "I'm going to push
some lube into your ass... okay, are you ready?" "Oh yes Daddy, I've been
dreaming about this all day. Do it."

With that, I lubed up Tara's ass as well as my cock then put it at the
entrance to Tara's ass and started pushing. "Relax your muscles, don't act as
if you need to hold something in." Tara relaxed and soon I had the head in.
"I've got the head inside. I'm going to give you a moment to get used to it."
"Uhh, ohhh, uuuh, ohhh oh Daddy, it feels sooo big. Ohhh." "Do you want me to
stop?" I asked. "NO. Keep going." Tara replied. "Okay, but remember your
promise. If it hurts too much, tell me to stop, okay?" "Yes, Daddy, keep
going." Tara answered.

I pushed again and soon I had all of my cock up inside her ass. I stopped
again for a moment to let Tara get used to the feeling and then started
stroking in and out. I'd occasionally had anal sex with mature women before
and could never get over the tight feeling of their ass but nothing prepared
me for just how tight Tara felt. I needed to keep a rein on my arousal so that
I could make sure Tara got off as well. I slowed down, then sped up and
simultaneously, reached down to tweak her nipples or play with her clit. The
first time I touched her pussy after I'd got my cock all the way into her ass
I was astounded at just how much pussy juice she'd produced.

It didn't take long before I could sense she was getting close and I put all
my efforts into fucking her ass. Suddenly I felt Tara tense up and start to
moan as she came. That was all it took for me to cum. I could feel Tara
getting ready to collapse forward and reached down and held her up, keeping my
cock in her ass. "Well, did you like having your daddy's big cock in your ass,
fucking you?" I asked. Tara turned her head and looked at me, first with a bit
of a surprised look on her face, then with a smile.

"Oh Daddy, it was such an incredible feeling... and I loved it when... when
you talked dirty to me... 'your daddy's big cock in your ass'... that sounded
so strange." she said.

I took one of the towels I'd placed on the bed and eased her off my cock,
putting the towel over her gaping asshole. "Hold this in place then hustle
into the bathroom. You'll leak for a bit." I said and Tara did as I suggested.
I took the other towel and wiped the worst of the cum and shit off my cock and
followed Tara. As I washed by cock off, I asked Tara if she was okay. "I'll be
okay in a couple of minutes. You go back to bed and I'll be there soon."
Pretty soon, Tara came back and joined me in bed. I cuddled and kissed her and
soon we were asleep.

The next morning I asked her how she felt. "Okay, I guess. I'm a bit sore...
you know... back there." I suggested she take the day off school – there
wasn't anything urgent that she couldn't catch up with later. Tara agreed and
after breakfast, went back to her room and lay down on the bed. After a bit I
went up to check on her. She seemed to be almost asleep but had a funny look
on her face.

"Are you sure you're okay?" I asked. "You look like you might be in pain."

Tara looked at me and smiled. "Nope. Just thinking about what a wonderful
daddy I've got. You've done what I asked and always did it with concern for my
feelings and making sure I wasn't hurt or uncomfortable. What more could a
young girl ask for when it came to her first sexual experiences?"

"Okay, sweetie, just checking. Go back to dreaming." and with that I left
closing the door behind me. Later that morning Tara came back into the kitchen
and said she was going to go for a walk. I asked if she wanted me to come with
her but she said she wanted to walk by herself. "I've got some things to think
about." she said and off she went.

An hour or so she came back and went back to her room and soon I heard the
shower running. When Tara came back out to where I was she said she was going
to go over to talk to 'Grandma Mabel' and off she went. Pretty soon Ashley
came home and asked where Tara was. I told her and Ashley got an 'Oh I see!'
look on her face and went to change out of her school clothes. Ashley and I
started supper and just as it was about ready, Tara came home and helped us
serve the meal. I could tell that Tara had something on her mind but I knew I
needed to let her tell me what it was when she was ready.

After the supper cleanup was completed, the three of us watched a movie I'd
recorded and soon Ashley said she had some homework to do and disappeared into
her room. I looked at Tara who, for the longest time, didn't say anything.
Finally, she got up, went into talk to Ashley then came back and sat on my
lap.

"Dad, last night was one of the most intense nights I've ever had. I was
thinking about what we did when I went walking this afternoon." She looked at
me and I nodded. "When I got to Grandma Mabel's she called Grandma Helen and
asked her to come over and the three of us talked over what had happened." She
paused for quite a long time. "I didn't know if I liked it or not. One moment
I was sure I did then the next I was sure I wouldn't do it again. The grandmas
said it had to be my decision but gave me a few things to think about."

I smiled at her. "Tara, what the grandmas said is absolutely correct. It must
be your decision." Tara smiled at me. "I talked to Ashley and said I wanted to
have another night with you alone and she said it was okay. Can we go to bed?
I want to kiss and cuddle." she asked. "Of course," I said, got up and taking
Tara's hand we walked to the bedroom. We dis as she'd asked, kissed and
cuddled and soon were asleep.

The next few weeks seemed to be back to normal with one or both of the girls
in my bed most nights and nothing was said by Tara about her anal sex
experience. Finally one day when we were in the house alone – Ashley was at a
friend's for a birthday party – Tara came and sat on my lap. "Dad, I've
finally decided that, at least for now, I won't let anyone fuck my ass." She
looked at me to see what my reaction was.

"Tara, my love, if you remember, I was hesitant at us having anal sex. I
respected your request, but now I'm glad you decided that you don't want to do
it anymore." I paused as I tried to gather my thoughts. "Anal sex between two
loving individuals can be a very erotic experience but it is an act that
really should only be done by fully grown adults. What we did scared the
living daylights out of me. I was worried that I'd do some damage or that I'd
miss hearing you say 'stop'. I don't regret what we did as it was a fantastic
gift that you gave me." and with that I pulled Tara into my arms and hugged
her.